Anti-abuse rules affecting an ETVE
Last reviewed:
An ETVE must examine separately the requirements of the regime, the source and nature of each item of income, the anti-abuse clause of the applicable tax treaty and the taxation of the shareholder. The actual decisions taken and the business reasons that can be evidenced are relevant to that analysis.
By René Dechamps Azanza, lawyer (Madrid Bar no. 21.297), founder of the firm (1982)
In short
- Article 21 of the Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS) denies the participation exemption, subject to its exceptions, for subsidiaries in non-cooperative jurisdictions, for dividends that are deductible at source and, in part, for disposals of asset-holding entities.
- Check the principal purpose test applicable under each treaty. It may deny a benefit where obtaining it was one of the principal purposes, unless granting it is in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions.
- Where an interposed company is involved, check separately the entitlement to the exemption under the Directive and to treaty benefits. For dividends, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and the Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal, TEAC) require the indicators to be assessed and the abusive practice to be proven.
- The Spanish CFC rules (transparencia fiscal internacional, art. 100 LIS) may reach controlled, low-taxed subsidiaries of the ETVE with passive income, if their conditions are met; the CFC rules of the shareholder's country are a separate layer.
- Pillar 2 only applies to groups with consolidated net turnover of at least €750 million in two of the four preceding periods; dividends and capital gains are subject to their own adjustments under art. 10 of Ley 7/2024 (Spanish Complementary Tax Act).
Which anti-abuse rules affect an ETVE?
Six layers, which are in addition to the requirements of Articles 107 and 108 LIS. Complying with the regime is not enough: each layer has its own test.
| Layer | Rule | What it examines |
|---|---|---|
| Incoming income | Art. 21 LIS | Where the subsidiary is located, what income it pays and what assets it holds |
| Payments to EU shareholders | Art. 14.1.h of the texto refundido de la Ley del Impuesto sobre la Renta de no Residentes (Consolidated Text of the Spanish Non-Resident Income Tax Act, TRLIRNR) | Who controls the European parent company and why |
| Tax treaties | Multilateral Instrument (MLI) and treaty-specific clauses | The principal purpose of the transaction, in the light of the facts |
| Payments covered by a treaty or directive | Beneficial ownership and the prohibition of abuse | Whether the ETVE enjoys what it receives or acts as a conduit |
| Passive subsidiaries | Art. 100 LIS | Low-taxed passive income |
| Shareholder | Its domestic rules (CFC) | Whether the shareholder is already taxed on undistributed profits |
Above all of these sit the general rules of the LGT: abuse of tax legislation (conflicto en la aplicación de la norma tributaria, Article 15 LGT) and sham transactions (simulación, art. 16 LGT).
What anti-abuse clauses does Article 21 contain?
Four, and any of them can deny the exemption for a specific item of income even if the ETVE complies with the regime. They are set out in detail in requirements:
- Subsidiary in a non-cooperative jurisdiction. The exemption does not apply, unless the subsidiary is resident in the European Union and valid economic reasons and economic activities are evidenced (art. 21.1.b). The law still refers to a "tax haven", but this is to be read as a non-cooperative jurisdiction (tenth additional provision, paragraph 1, Ley 36/2006; the definition is in the first additional provision). The Spanish list (Orden HFP/115/2023) was amended by Orden HAC/649/2026, with its own transitional regime: as at 15 November 2026 it has 18 operative entries, but it is necessary to check which version applies to each tax period. The EU list (revised on 9 October 2026) has 8 jurisdictions in its Annex I. They are different lists: for the ETVE, the Spanish list prevails.
- Dividends deductible in the subsidiary. There is no exemption if the payment gave rise to a deductible expense for the payer (art. 21.1), which targets hybrid instruments.
- Intermediate holding companies. If more than 70% of the subsidiary's income consists of dividends or capital gains, the ETVE also needs an indirect 5% holding in the lower-tier companies, subject to exceptions (art. 21.1.a).
- Disposal of asset-holding entities or entities subject to CFC rules. On the disposal of an asset-holding investee (art. 5.2), only the portion corresponding to profits not distributed during the holding period is exempt (art. 21.5.a). There is no exemption if at least 15% of the investee's income is subject to the CFC rules (art. 21.5.c).
What happens when the ETVE pays a shareholder in the European Union?
The parent-subsidiary exemption (art. 14.1.h TRLIRNR) does not apply if the majority of the voting rights in the European parent company are held, directly or indirectly, by persons outside the EU or the EEA, unless its incorporation and operations are based on "valid economic reasons and substantive business reasons".
If the distribution complies with art. 108.1.c LIS, it is deemed to be obtained outside Spain (see distributions to non-resident shareholders). For Spanish-source dividends paid to an EU or EEA parent company, check the conditions of art. 14.1.h and the exclusion in art. 14.2. Applying the anti-abuse clause requires an assessment of the circumstances of the case.
The current wording of that clause derives from Ley 26/2014, with effect from 2015. For dividends, the TEAC (decision of 27 January 2026, RG 00/02180/2022) places the burden of proving abuse on the tax authorities.
What is the principal purpose test (PPT)?
It is a clause that may deny a benefit where it is reasonable to conclude, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining it was one of the principal purposes of the transaction, unless granting it is in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions. Spain opted for the MLI's PPT and retained certain pre-existing bilateral clauses.
The MLI entered into force for Spain on 1 January 2022, but it takes effect on different dates depending on each treaty and each tax. It only modifies a treaty if both countries have listed and ratified it. According to the Ministry of Finance website (November 2026):
| Treaty | Status |
|---|---|
| Chile, Costa Rica, Panama, Uruguay, Belgium, France, Argentina | Synthesised text published: the MLI modifies the treaty |
| Mexico | Synthesised text published; retains the anti-abuse clause of its Protocol, owing to a reservation by Spain |
| Colombia, Ecuador, Brazil, Dominican Republic, Venezuela | Listed by Spain, no synthesised text published |
| Netherlands | The 1971 treaty remains in force, not modified by the MLI |
| United States | Has not signed the MLI; its Protocol (in force since 27/11/2019) includes a limitation on benefits clause |
The Ministry of Finance list is an aid: the absence of a synthesised text does not mean that the MLI does not apply. For each treaty, it is necessary to cross-check the final lists of both States, their reservations, entry into force and the dates of effect.
The treaties with Ireland and Portugal contain their own clauses on companies engaged merely in holding securities and controlled by non-residents, which must be read in each case. The protocols with Croatia and Vietnam contain specific safeguards for the ETVE against their own limitations; they do not remove the other conditions of the treaty or the PPT or other subsequent rules. Details are given in countries and in treaties and agreements.
Who is the beneficial owner, and when does it matter?
The beneficial owner is the person who enjoys the income and can decide on it. Check whether the treaty or directive imposes that requirement. Under the Parent-Subsidiary Directive, the CJEU applies the prohibition of abuse when examining conduit companies. The Interest and Royalties Directive does expressly require the recipient to be the beneficial owner.
In the "Danish cases" (26 February 2019: Cases C-116/16 and C-117/16, on dividends, and C-115/16 and joined cases, on interest), the Court of Justice of the EU identified indicators of abuse that are to be assessed as a whole: passing on almost all of what is received shortly afterwards, an insignificant margin, lack of own resources and obligations to pay another party.
For dividends, the CJEU allows the parent-subsidiary exemption to be denied where the tax authorities establish an abusive practice. The TEAC applies that test and places the burden of proving abuse on the tax authorities. Any treaty benefit is examined in the light of the relevant clause and the facts of the case.
For the ETVE, the consequence is twofold. In the subsidiary's country, if the treaty so requires, it must be the beneficial owner in order to obtain the reduced withholding tax rate. In Spain, Article 108 contains no beneficial ownership clause, but Articles 15 and 16 LGT still apply. The minimum accepted by the Dirección General de Tributos (Spanish Directorate-General for Taxation, DGT) for the regime (a director with real management capacity) is not sufficient on its own for this purpose (see substance).
Example: three separate checks for the same dividend
The same dividend flow goes through three separate tests, each with its own rule and its own evidence; passing one does not resolve the others. Suppose an ETVE with a subsidiary in a treaty country, an individual shareholder resident outside the EU and another shareholder that is a company in another EU Member State.
| Check | Rule | What must be evidenced |
|---|---|---|
| Withholding tax in the subsidiary's country | Treaty with that country and, where applicable, the MLI | The conditions of the dividends article (percentage, holding period, legal form of the recipient), beneficial ownership if the treaty requires it and the PPT or the relevant treaty-specific clause |
| Distribution to the non-resident shareholder out of exempt foreign-source income | Art. 108.1.c and 108.4 LIS | That the profit derives from income exempt under art. 21 obtained from non-resident entities (or under art. 22), that the shareholder has no permanent establishment in Spain and that it is not resident in a non-cooperative jurisdiction. If met, the profit is not deemed to be obtained in Spain |
| Distribution to the European parent company of profits not deriving from that income | Art. 14.1.h and 14.2 TRLIRNR | At least a 5% direct or indirect holding for one year (or until that period is completed), the legal form and taxation of the parent company, that the distribution does not arise from a liquidation and, if the majority of its voting rights are held by persons outside the EU or the EEA, valid economic reasons and substantive business reasons |
The substance test also varies depending on the benefit claimed. For the regime, what counts is the organisation of material and human resources and actual management in Spain (art. 107.1 LIS). For the treaty, beneficial ownership and the purpose of the transaction. For the parent-subsidiary exemption, the reasons for the incorporation and operations of the European parent company. For art. 108 there is no specific test of this kind, but Articles 15 and 16 LGT remain applicable.
When do the Spanish CFC rules affect the ETVE?
When the ETVE controls a low-taxed foreign subsidiary that obtains passive income. Article 100 LIS requires that income to be included in the ETVE's tax base even if it is not distributed, if the following conditions are met simultaneously:
- the ETVE, alone or together with related persons, holds at least 50% of the share capital, equity, profits or voting rights;
- the tax actually paid under an identical or similar tax, attributable to the categories of income to be examined, is less than 75% of the tax that would have been payable under the rules of Spanish Corporate Income Tax;
- if there are resources and the category-by-category test applies, the positive income listed in art. 100.3 is attributed. The exemption applies if the total is less than 15% of total income, subject to the statutory exception for certain related-party transactions (art. 100.4: the income referred to in letter i of art. 100.3 is attributed in all cases). Also review foreign permanent establishments.
If there are no resources, total income may be attributed, unless evidence is provided on the terms of art. 100.2. For EU or EEA entities, check the exception where the taxpayer evidences that they carry out economic activities and the exception for certain collective investment undertakings (art. 100.15 LIS). A subsidiary's nominal tax rate may satisfy the taxation threshold in art. 21 and, at the same time, its effective taxation may require a CFC analysis.
And the rules of the shareholder's country?
They are another layer, and often the decisive one. Many countries tax shareholders on the profits of their low-taxed foreign companies even if they are not distributed: Mexico's Refipre, Colombia's controlled foreign entities regime and Argentina's fiscal transparency rules, among others. Since the ETVE may be taxed in Spain at around 1.25% on exempt dividends (95% exemption and 25% general rate), it may fall within those regimes, in which case the deferral may be lost.
Several countries in the region also penalise payments to low-tax territories. We analyse this country by country in countries.
What is the risk of contributing the subsidiaries to the ETVE?
The tax neutrality regime (régimen FEAC) does not apply if the main purpose of the transaction is tax fraud or evasion, in particular where there are no valid economic reasons (art. 89.2 LIS).
The adjustment is limited to eliminating the effects of the abusive tax advantage. The TEAC has examined contributions of shareholdings followed by distributions of profits or by indirectly obtaining access to them (decisions of 27/05/2024, RG 00/06513/2022 and 00/06550/2022, and of 19/11/2024, RG 00/08869/2021), and in its decision of 8 October 2026 (RG 00/00417/2023) it insists on identifying and attributing the specific abusive advantage. Check the reasons for the transaction and the actual use of the profits in each case file. See administrative doctrine and case law.
Does Pillar 2 affect an ETVE?
Pillar 2 applies to large-scale multinational and domestic groups whose net turnover, according to the consolidated financial statements of the ultimate parent entity, has been at least €750m in two of the four tax periods immediately preceding, subject to the statutory adjustments and exclusions (arts. 1, 6 and 7 Ley 7/2024). A top-up tax may arise if the effective tax rate per jurisdiction is below 15%, in accordance with its calculation rules. A group that does not reach that threshold falls outside its scope.
Ley 7/2024 provides for separate adjustments for dividends and for capital gains or losses. For dividends, check the group's percentage holding, the holding period of the recipient, investment entities and the filing entity's elections: the filing constituent entity may elect, for each constituent entity of the group, not to apply the exclusion of those dividends for a minimum period of five tax periods (art. 10.2.b). For gains, check the specific case in art. 10.1.c and how its cross-reference to the concept of portfolio shareholding (participación no significativa) applies.
Must the ETVE be reported under DAC6?
Not merely because it exists. The obligation (twenty-third additional provision LGT, Ley 10/2020, Form 234) arises when a cross-border arrangement meets any of the "hallmarks" of Directive 2018/822.
The hallmarks include certain deductible cross-border payments between associated enterprises, structures that convert income and arrangements with non-transparent beneficial ownership. Some hallmarks require the main benefit test to be verified. Failure to report on time is penalised with €2,000 per item or set of data relating to an arrangement, with a minimum of €4,000 and the statutory maximum. Other breaches are subject to their own rules.
What are the consequences of a tax adjustment?
The right to assess tax is time-barred, as a general rule, after four years (art. 66 LGT). Review when the period starts and any interruptions (arts. 67 and 68 LGT) and the review of tax credits or facts from time-barred years that have effects in other open years (arts. 66 bis and 115 LGT). The penalty for failure to pay depends on the infringement and the degree of fault (arts. 179 and 191 LGT). In cases of conflict in the application of the rule, substantial equivalence with a published criterion is required, under the conditions of art. 206 bis LGT.
How to prepare an ETVE for a tax audit?
No checklist guarantees the outcome, but these guidelines from the firm help to document each test:
- A written business reason before incorporation: organising the group, the entry of shareholders, succession, expansion.
- Actual decisions taken in Spain, with a director with full powers, and minutes and emails to prove it.
- Substance proportionate to the group, increasing as the portfolio grows.
- No automatic passing-on: dividends are resolved upon, reinvested or distributed by decision of the general meeting, not by contract.
- Each subsidiary reviewed against art. 21 and art. 100: the list of jurisdictions applicable to the period, taxation and passive income.
- Each treaty reviewed in light of the MLI, the PPT and its specific clauses.
- Each shareholder's country analysed before starting (CFC, anti-tax-haven rules).
- The contribution justified if the FEAC regime is applied, with no immediate distributions that contradict it.
- Separate notes to the accounts and reserves, with tax residence certificates of the shareholders as at the date of each distribution.
- Annual review, including DAC6 for each new transaction.
For the initial steps, see step-by-step incorporation.
Is an ETVE right for you? Try the simulator: requirements check and an indicative Spanish tax cost.
Frequently asked questions
If I meet the ETVE requirements, am I no longer affected by anti-abuse rules?
No. The ETVE regime governs taxation in Spain if its requirements are met, but each tax treaty, the parent-subsidiary exemption, the CFC rules and the general rules of the Ley General Tributaria (Spanish General Taxation Act, LGT) are subject to their own examination. The actual decisions taken and the business reasons that can be evidenced count in that analysis, but they do not guarantee the outcome.
What is the beneficial owner?
It is the person who enjoys the income and can decide on it. You need to check whether the applicable treaty or directive imposes that requirement. For dividends within the EU, the tax authorities may deny the exemption under the Directive if they establish an abusive practice, for example through an interposed company that passes on what it receives.
Does Pillar 2 affect my family ETVE?
Normally not. It only applies to groups with consolidated net turnover of at least €750 million in two of the four preceding periods, subject to the statutory adjustments and exclusions.
Do I have to report the ETVE as a tax planning arrangement (DAC6)?
An ordinary ETVE, on its own, does not usually meet the hallmarks that trigger a reporting obligation. This must be reviewed arrangement by arrangement, particularly where there are certain deductible cross-border payments between associated enterprises; some hallmarks only count if the main benefit test is also met.
Sources
- Ley 27/2014, del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act), arts. 5.2, 21, 89.2, 100, 107 and 108
- Real Decreto Legislativo 5/2004, texto refundido de la Ley del IRNR (Consolidated Text of the Spanish Non-Resident Income Tax Act), art. 14.1.h and 14.2
- Ley 26/2014 (current wording of the anti-abuse clause in art. 14.1.h TRLIRNR)
- Ley 58/2003, General Tributaria (Spanish General Taxation Act), arts. 15, 16, 66, 66 bis, 67, 68, 115, 179, 191 and 206 bis and twenty-third additional provision
- Ley 36/2006, first and tenth additional provisions (non-cooperative jurisdictions)
- Orden HFP/115/2023 (Spanish list of non-cooperative jurisdictions)
- Orden HAC/649/2026 (amendment of the list and transitional regime)
- Instrument of ratification of the Multilateral Convention (BOE of 22/12/2021), arts. 7 and 35 and Spain's reservations
- Spanish Ministry of Finance: tax treaties and synthesised texts of the Multilateral Convention
- Protocol to the Spain-Mexico tax treaty, point 1.b
- Protocol to the Spain-United States tax treaty, art. IX (limitation on benefits)
- CJEU, judgment of 26/02/2019, Cases C-116/16 and C-117/16 (dividends)
- CJEU, judgment of 26/02/2019, Case C-115/16 and joined cases (interest)
- TEAC, decision of 27/01/2026, RG 00/02180/2022
- TEAC, decision of 19/11/2024, RG 00/08869/2021
- TEAC, decision of 27/05/2024, RG 00/06513/2022
- TEAC, decision of 27/05/2024, RG 00/06550/2022
- TEAC, decision of 08/10/2026, RG 00/00417/2023
- Ley 7/2024, Complementary Tax (Pillar 2), arts. 1, 6, 7 and 10
- Ley 10/2020 (DAC6: reportable cross-border tax planning arrangements)
- Real Decreto 243/2021 (implementing regulations for DAC6 in the RGAT)
This guide provides general information as of November 15, 2026 and is not advice on any specific case.
How we can help
For many years the firm has advised entrepreneurs and families from Latin America on setting up, acquiring, relocating and maintaining ETVEs: preliminary analysis, articles of association, contribution of shares, notification to the tax authorities, management from Spain and an annual substance review, in coordination with their local advisers.
The first meeting with René Dechamps Azanza, founder of the practice, is free of charge: in person in Madrid or by video call. Write to us at rda@rdalex.com or call +34 91 308 71 73.
Request a first meetingOr call us on +34 91 308 71 73 · rda@rdalex.com
