The ETVE compared with holding companies in the Netherlands, Luxembourg and Malta (and what to check in Cyprus)
Last reviewed:
Spain can fit groups with shareholders and subsidiaries in Latin America. Compare the withholding tax on distributions from each subsidiary, taxation in the holding company, the distribution to the shareholder and taxation in the shareholder's country of residence. Apply the substance and anti-abuse requirements of each transaction.
By René Dechamps Azanza, lawyer (Madrid Bar no. 21.297), founder of the firm (1982)
In short
- Participation exemption: in Spain, the exemption under Art. 21 LIS is calculated on 95% of the income (theoretical cost of 1.25% at 25%); the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Malta and Cyprus apply their own exemption rules and conditions, which must be checked in each case.
- Exit to non-EU shareholders: no Spanish withholding tax on distributions that meet Art. 108 LIS; the Netherlands and Luxembourg start from a general domestic rate of 15%, with exemptions; in Malta and Cyprus this must be verified for the specific shareholder and regime.
- In the sample of 14 countries identified in the table, Spain has 13 tax treaties in force. For the other jurisdictions, check country by country whether the treaty is in force and already has effect for the income and the date of the transaction.
- Substance: it is tested under the rule granting each benefit. Art. 107 LIS requires an organisation of resources; withholding tax at the subsidiary depends on the tax treaty, its anti-abuse clause and, where relevant, proof of beneficial ownership.
- Spain usually makes more sense with non-EU shareholders, subsidiaries in Latin America and real management in Spanish; less so with a shareholder and subsidiaries within the EU.
What changes between an ETVE and a holding company in the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Malta or Cyprus?
Spain, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Malta and Cyprus provide, with different requirements and scope, regimes for dividends and capital gains from subsidiaries. The differences that weigh most are usually in the exit to the shareholders, in the tax treaties with the subsidiaries' countries and in the substance required for each benefit.
The ETVE is a Spanish company that elects the regime of Articles 107 and 108 of the Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS). The exemption for dividends and capital gains from subsidiaries is in Article 21 LIS and is available to any Spanish company that meets its requirements. What is specific to the ETVE is Article 108: what it distributes to non-resident shareholders out of that exempt income is not treated as obtained in Spain, if its conditions are met.
Figures for other countries appear only if we have checked them in their official source; we state the date of each source.
Comparative table with sources and consultation dates by jurisdiction
| Criterion | Spain (ETVE) | Netherlands (BV) | Luxembourg (Soparfi) | Malta | Cyprus |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exemption for dividends and capital gains from subsidiaries | On 95% of the income (theoretical cost ≈1.25% at 25%). 5% and one year. Subsidiary taxed at a nominal rate of at least 10% or with a tax treaty | 100%. 5%, no minimum holding period. Special rules for low-taxed portfolio shareholdings | 100%. Dividends: 10% or €1.2m (Art. 166 LIR); capital gains: 10% or €6m (regulation). 12-month holding or commitment. Conditions for the investee | 100%, or pay tax and obtain a refund. 5% or other routes, such as investing €1,164,000 for 183 days. Conditions for non-EU subsidiaries | Conditions to be verified under current Cypriot legislation for each type of income and investee |
| Withholding tax on distributions to non-EU shareholders | No withholding tax on distributions that meet Art. 108.1.c and 4. In other cases, review the IRNR and the tax treaty | 15% general domestic rate, with exemptions and conditional withholding tax in specified cases | 15% general domestic rate, with exemptions and applicable tax treaties | Verify withholding tax for the specific shareholder and regime | Verify withholding tax and defensive measures for the specific shareholder |
| Tax treaties in the sample of 14 countries | 13 in force | See status by country and date of source | See status by country and date of source | Mexico and Uruguay appear in the Maltese orders consulted | Check each treaty in the current official Cypriot source |
| Corporate income tax rate | 25% general | 19% up to €200,000 and 25.8% on the excess | 23.87% aggregate nominal rate for the top band in Luxembourg City | 35% general. Optional final regime of 15% subject to conditions | Verify the applicable rate under current Cypriot legislation |
| Substance | Organisation of resources for the regime (Art. 107 LIS); for withholding tax at the subsidiary, tax treaty and anti-abuse rules | Criteria on management, payroll costs and office space within the scope of the exemption from its withholding tax | Official criteria for financing companies; for pure holding companies, general rules | Check residence, effective management and anti-abuse clauses of the benefit claimed | Check residence, effective management and anti-abuse clauses of the benefit claimed |
| Language and legal culture | Spanish, civil law close to Latin American law | Dutch and English | French, German, Luxembourgish and English | English and Maltese | Greek and English |
| ATAD, Pillar Two, Multilateral Convention | All five are in the EU: they apply the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD) and, for groups with consolidated revenue of at least €750m, Pillar Two, which is determined at group level. The effect of the Multilateral Convention and its principal purpose test depends on each tax treaty and its dates of effect |
Sources and dates: Spain, BOE consolidated text of the LIS and the TRLIRNR (consulted on 14/11/2026) and the Ministry of Finance list of tax treaties (updated to 26/05/2026). Netherlands, wetten.overheid.nl (versions as at 1/1/2026) and the Belastingdienst list of tax treaties of January 2026. Luxembourg, coordinated text of the LIR as at 1/1/2026 and the list of tax treaties of the Administration des contributions directes (Direct Tax Administration) of 23/07/2026, which gives dates of application. Malta, legislation.mt (Income Tax Act in its version of 10/03/2026). For Cyprus no firm figures are included and reference is made to checking its current official sources.
Participation exemption in Spain: 95% of qualifying income
In Spain, the general exemption of Article 21 LIS is calculated on 95% of the income that meets its requirements. At the general rate of 25%, the theoretical cost is 1.25%. Paragraph 11 provides a limited exception for certain dividends. In the other jurisdictions, check the exemption for dividends and for capital gains separately. We explain this in tax benefits.
The requirements also differ:
- The Netherlands requires 5% of the capital and no minimum holding period (Art. 13 Wet Vpb). It excludes low-taxed portfolio shareholdings, unless they pass its taxation or asset tests.
- Luxembourg. For dividends, Art. 166 LIR requires 10% or an acquisition cost of €1.2m. For capital gains, the implementing regulation applies 10% or €6m, with specific conditions of calculation and possible recapture of expenses. In both cases, review the uninterrupted 12-month holding, or the commitment where applicable, and the status of the investee.
- Malta allows several routes for a "participating holding". For non-EU subsidiaries it requires, for example, that they are taxed at no less than 15% or that no more than half of their income derives from passive interest or royalties (Art. 12(1)(u) Income Tax Act).
- Spain requires 5% and a one-year holding, and that the subsidiary is taxed at a nominal rate of at least 10% or is resident in a country with a tax treaty containing an exchange of information clause (Art. 21.1 LIS). Many Latin American subsidiaries may qualify through the tax treaty route or by their rate, but this must be checked in each case.
- Cyprus: the conditions for exempting dividends and gains on the disposal of securities must be verified under current Cypriot legislation for each type of income and investee.
In a pure holding company, the nominal corporate income tax rate matters little if almost all its income is exempt. Comparing the Spanish 25% with the Dutch 19% is misleading.
Withholding tax on distributions to shareholders outside the EU
For a shareholder living in Mexico, Colombia or Costa Rica, Spain does not tax the profits that the ETVE distributes out of exempt income, if the conditions of Article 108 LIS are met. The Netherlands and Luxembourg start from a general domestic withholding tax of 15%, with exemptions.
- Spain. Profits out of exempt income are not treated as obtained in Spain if the shareholder is not resident here, has no permanent establishment and is not resident in a non-cooperative jurisdiction (Art. 108 LIS). No tax treaty with the shareholder's country is needed. Profits out of other income are taxed at 19% (Art. 25.1.f TRLIRNR), unless an exemption or a tax treaty applies. Details in distributions to non-resident shareholders.
- The Netherlands. The general domestic rate is 15%. There is an exemption for certain corporate recipients that meet the requirements and the anti-abuse test. Since 2024, for certain related entities and cases of low taxation, abuse and other statutory situations, the conditional withholding tax may apply, at a rate of 25.8% in 2026. Check how it is coordinated with the ordinary withholding tax and the tax treaty.
- Luxembourg. It withholds 15% (Art. 148 LIR) and exempts companies from tax treaty countries subject to a comparable tax, with 10% or €1.2m held for 12 months (Art. 147 LIR). An individual is, in principle, subject to 15%, unless the tax treaty sets a lower limit. It does not withhold on liquidation proceeds, although the gain may be taxed there in some cases.
- Malta and Cyprus. Withholding tax requires checking the payer's regime, the shareholder's residence and connection, and the current exceptions. No general exit rate for payments to non-residents is given here.
As against Malta and Cyprus, the exit must be analysed for each shareholder. In every jurisdiction, the tax treaties with the subsidiaries' countries also carry weight.
The tax treaty network with Latin America: Spain's great advantage
Spain has a tax treaty in force with 13 of the 14 countries in this sample. For each jurisdiction, check the tax treaty and its date of effect for the specific income. Withholding tax at the subsidiary also depends on domestic law and on the eligibility of the recipient.
| Subsidiary's country | Spain (Ministry of Finance, 26/05/2026) | Netherlands (Belastingdienst, January 2026) | Luxembourg (ACD, 23/07/2026) | Malta (orders on legislation.mt) | Cyprus (check in its official source) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mexico | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Verify |
| Colombia | Yes | Signed (2022), not in force | Signed (2024), not in force | Not listed | Verify |
| Chile | Yes | Yes (2022) | Under negotiation | Not listed | Verify |
| Argentina | Yes | Yes | Signed (2019), not in force | Not listed | Verify |
| Brazil | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not listed | Verify |
| Peru | Signed (2006), not in force | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Ecuador | Yes | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Costa Rica | Yes | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Venezuela | Yes | Yes | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Uruguay | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Verify |
| Panama | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not listed | Verify |
| Dominican Republic | Yes | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Paraguay | In force since 14/10/2024. Ordinary effect from 01/01/2025 | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
| Bolivia | Yes | No | No | Not listed | Verify |
"Not listed" means that we have not found a tax treaty in the official source consulted; it is not equivalent to a comprehensive check that none exists. "Verify" indicates that the status of the tax treaty must be checked in that country's official source before deciding. The date of entry into force and the date of effect do not necessarily coincide: both must be checked for each tax and transaction.
Spain has bilateral investment protection agreements in the region. Check whether the applicable agreement is in force and, if it has been terminated, whether protection remains for investments already made. More detail in tax treaties and agreements.
A tax treaty does not apply automatically. The subsidiary will check that the holding company meets its requirements and, where the tax treaty is affected by the Multilateral Convention (in force for Spain since 1 January 2022, with its own dates of effect for each tax treaty), the principal purpose test. The tax treaty between Spain and the Netherlands is still the 1971 one, and Spain did not include it in the Multilateral Convention. See anti-abuse rules.
Substance requirements for each tax benefit
Substance is tested under the rule granting each benefit. For the regime, Article 107 LIS requires an organisation of material and personnel resources, with no statutory minimum figures. For the tax treaty, the onward flow of income, who takes the decisions and the resources are indicators that are assessed as a whole (Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 26 February 2019, cases C-116/16 and C-117/16).
- The Netherlands. Within the scope of the Dutch exemption from withholding tax, there are criteria on management, payroll costs and available office space. Meeting them affects the burden of proof of abuse. Check their scope and conditions before extrapolating them to a BV that receives foreign income.
- Luxembourg sets out its "real presence" requirements for intra-group financing companies: a majority of resident directors, qualified staff and decisions taken in Luxembourg. For pure holding companies we have not found specific official criteria.
- Malta and Cyprus: the requirements of residence, effective management and anti-abuse clauses applicable to the benefit claimed must be checked in each case.
The detail of the Spanish requirement is in substance.
When investing in Spain through another European holding company, review the conditions of Art. 14.1.h TRLIRNR and the possible application of its anti-abuse clause. The rule distinguishes control from the EU and from EEA States that meet the statutory requirements. In a dividend case, the Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal, TEAC) placed the burden of proving abuse on the tax authorities (decision of 27 January 2026, RG 00/02180/2022).
Language, proximity and reputation
A holding company is managed every year, not only on the day it is incorporated. Board meetings, minutes, banks and tax inspections in Spanish, with company law similar to that of Latin America, can reduce errors and coordination costs.
Spain is not a low-tax jurisdiction (general rate of 25%, Art. 29 LIS) and the ETVE regime has been governed by statute since 1995. Even so, each shareholder remains subject to the CFC rules of their own country, which may cancel out the saving (countries).
In terms of cost, no jurisdiction is free: the cost must be weighed against the saving and the legal certainty (costs).
What about other jurisdictions or structures?
Ireland, Belgium, Switzerland and Portugal also have participation exemption regimes; we do not compare them with figures. The key question is the same: tax treaties with the subsidiaries' countries and withholding tax on shareholders. For Belgian or Dutch shareholders, see Belgium and the Netherlands.
An investor from the United States should compare the ETVE with investing directly under the tax treaty with the subsidiary's country: see United States.
Groups with consolidated revenue of at least €750m must review Pillar Two (in Spain, Ley 7/2024 (Act 7/2024)) in any European jurisdiction; it is determined at group level, not at the level of the holding company in isolation. In Spain, in addition, the 15% minimum taxation of Article 30 bis LIS, where applicable, is calculated on the tax base, from which exempt income has already been excluded. In a pure ETVE it usually has little effect.
When does Spain make most sense?
Spain usually makes most sense when the shareholders live outside the EU and the subsidiaries are in Latin America. The typical case is a Mexican, Colombian or Costa Rican family with businesses in several countries in the region.
It usually fits when:
- the shareholders are individuals or companies from outside the EU who are not resident in non-cooperative jurisdictions;
- the subsidiaries are in countries with a tax treaty with Spain that is in force and has effect for the income concerned;
- the aim is to manage in Spanish, with real decisions taken in Madrid or another Spanish city;
- a sale of subsidiaries or, later on, of the holding company itself is envisaged (Art. 108.2.b LIS).
It usually adds little when:
- the shareholder is an EU company and so are the subsidiaries: the Parent-Subsidiary Directive already allows distributions without withholding tax if its requirements are met;
- the shareholder is resident in Spain and does not intend to reinvest (family holding company);
- the company cannot be given real management from Spain;
- the shareholder's country taxes the holding company's profits in any event under its CFC rules.
The outcome depends on each case. We review the group, the country of each shareholder and that of each subsidiary before recommending a jurisdiction.
Is an ETVE right for you? Try the simulator: requirements check and an indicative Spanish tax cost.
Frequently asked questions
Is a holding company in the Netherlands or Luxembourg better than an ETVE for investing in Latin America?
It depends on the case. Compare, country by country, whether the tax treaty with the subsidiary's country is in force and has effect, and the withholding tax on the shareholder: the Netherlands and Luxembourg start from a general domestic rate of 15% with exemptions, and the ETVE does not withhold on distributions that meet Art. 108 LIS. The shareholder's country of residence may change the outcome.
Why does the ETVE exempt only 95% of dividends and capital gains?
For tax periods beginning in 2021 onwards, Art. 21.10 LIS reduces the exempt amount by 5% as management expenses. At the general rate of 25%, the theoretical cost is 1.25%. That cost must be compared with the savings in withholding tax on the way in and on the way out.
Aren't Malta or Cyprus cheaper?
That cannot be stated as a general rule. Malta has a general rate of 35% and an optional final regime of 15% subject to conditions, and in Cyprus the applicable rate and the defensive rules must be verified for the specific shareholder. Moreover, of the 14 Latin American countries in the sample, only Malta's tax treaties with Mexico and Uruguay appear in the Maltese orders consulted.
Does Spain require less substance than the Netherlands?
No general comparison is possible. For the regime, Art. 107 LIS requires an organisation of resources. For withholding tax at the subsidiary, the tax treaty, its anti-abuse clause and, where relevant, proof of beneficial ownership are examined; the Dutch criteria relate to a specific exemption from their own withholding tax.
My shareholder is an EU company and my subsidiaries are also in the EU. Is an ETVE worthwhile for me?
It usually adds little. The Parent-Subsidiary Directive already allows dividends to be distributed without withholding tax between EU companies that meet its requirements and its anti-abuse clause. The ETVE usually makes the difference with non-EU shareholders and with subsidiaries in Latin America.
Sources
- Ley 27/2014, del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Corporate Income Tax Act 27/2014), Arts. 21, 29, 30 bis, 107 and 108 (consolidated text)
- Real Decreto Legislativo 5/2004, texto refundido de la Ley del IRNR (Royal Legislative Decree 5/2004, consolidated text of the Non-Resident Income Tax Act), Arts. 14.1.h and 25.1.f (consolidated text)
- Ley 7/2024, por la que se establece un Impuesto Complementario (Act 7/2024 establishing a Complementary Tax, Pillar Two)
- Multilateral Convention (MLI), Arts. 7, 8, 34 and 35, BOE of 22/12/2021
- Ministerio de Hacienda (Spanish Ministry of Finance): list of double taxation conventions
- Spain-Paraguay tax treaty, Art. 27 (entry into force and effect)
- Spain-Netherlands tax treaty of 16/06/1971 and Protocol
- Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal, TEAC), decision of 27/01/2026, RG 00/02180/2022
- Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 26/02/2019, cases C-116/16 and C-117/16
- Netherlands: Wet op de vennootschapsbelasting 1969, Arts. 13 (deelnemingsvrijstelling) and 22, 2026 version
- Netherlands: Wet op de dividendbelasting 1965, Arts. 4 and 5, 2026 version
- Netherlands: Belastingdienst, conditional withholding tax (bronbelasting)
- Netherlands: Belastingdienst, changes to corporate income tax 2026 (rates)
- Netherlands: Belastingdienst, Verdragsstaten IB niet-ingezetenen (January 2026)
- Netherlands: Uitvoeringsbeschikking dividendbelasting 1965, Art. 1bis
- Luxembourg: Loi concernant l'impôt sur le revenu (LIR), Arts. 147, 148, 166 and 174, coordinated text as at 1 January 2026 (ACD)
- Luxembourg: Guichet.lu, parent-subsidiary regime for Soparfis
- Luxembourg: ACD, tax burden of companies (aggregate rate)
- Luxembourg: ACD, double taxation conventions
- Malta: Income Tax Act (Cap. 123), Arts. 2, 12(1)(u) and 56(6), version of 10/03/2026
- Malta: Legal Notice 188 of 2025, Final Income Tax Without Imputation Regulations
- Malta: order implementing the tax treaty with Mexico (S.L. 123.151)
- Malta: order implementing the tax treaty with Uruguay (S.L. 123.144)
This guide provides general information as of November 15, 2026 and is not advice on any specific case.
How we can help
For many years the firm has advised entrepreneurs and families from Latin America on setting up, acquiring, relocating and maintaining ETVEs: preliminary analysis, articles of association, contribution of shares, notification to the tax authorities, management from Spain and an annual substance review, in coordination with their local advisers.
The first meeting with René Dechamps Azanza, founder of the practice, is free of charge: in person in Madrid or by video call. Write to us at rda@rdalex.com or call +34 91 308 71 73.
Request a first meetingOr call us on +34 91 308 71 73 · rda@rdalex.com
