ETVE guide · Spanish holding company

ETVE and the United States: the tax treaty, the LOB clause and the US shareholder

Last reviewed:

The tax treaty between Spain and the United States, amended by a Protocol in force since 27 November 2019, sets caps of 0%, 5% or 15% on withholding tax on dividends, each with its own conditions. An ETVE only has access to that treaty if it satisfies one of the routes in the limitation on benefits (LOB) clause in Article 17, which requires ownership and activity to be reviewed and may be difficult to meet for holding companies with non-European shareholders. For a US shareholder, if the ETVE is a controlled foreign corporation, the Subpart F and NCTI (formerly GILTI) rules may tax part of its profits in the US even if they are not distributed.

By René Dechamps Azanza, lawyer (Madrid Bar no. 21.297), founder of the firm (1982)

In short

  • Tax treaty of 22 February 1990 and Protocol of 14 January 2013, in force since 27 November 2019 (BOE, Spanish Official State Gazette, of 23 October 2019).
  • Dividends: general cap of 15%; 5% with a direct holding of at least 10% of the voting power; 0% under the corporate route in art. 10.3, with at least 80% of the voting power, 12 months and the specified LOB routes.
  • The LOB in art. 17 decides whether the ETVE can use the treaty; with Latin American shareholders it should be analysed shareholder by shareholder before investing.
  • If the ETVE is a CFC for US purposes, its qualifying US shareholders may be subject to Subpart F and NCTI (Public Law 119-21, tax years beginning from 2026).
  • The US has tax treaties with Chile, Mexico and Venezuela, but not with Argentina, Brazil, Colombia or Peru.

The United States appears in an ETVE in three ways: as the country of a subsidiary, as the country of residence of the shareholders and as the origin of investors looking towards Latin America. In all three cases the same tax treaty governs, with its own anti-abuse clause that is very different from those in the Latin American treaties.

Tax treaty between Spain and the United States

The treaty was signed in Madrid on 22 February 1990 and amended by a Protocol of 14 January 2013, which entered into force on 27 November 2019. It is not a pending reform: its effects are determined tax by tax under art. XV.2 of the Protocol (withholding taxes on amounts paid from that date and, for other taxes, tax years beginning on or after that date).

Issue What the treaty in force says
Dividends (art. 10) Caps of 15% in general, 5% with a direct holding of at least 10% of the voting power, and 0% under the corporate route in art. 10.3 with at least 80% of the voting power, the holding period and the specified LOB routes. The beneficial owner and the residence of interposed entities are checked where appropriate
Capital gains on the sale of shares (art. 13) The residual rule allocates the taxing right to the transferor's State of residence. Interests in immovable property and the assets of a permanent establishment, among the specific rules of the article, are examined first
Transparent entities (art. 1.6) Income derived through an LLC or a partnership is regarded as income of a resident to the extent that its country treats it as income of that resident
Limitation on benefits (art. 17) The treaty provides for qualified persons and additional routes, including derivative benefits, substantial activity in specific cases or a grant by the competent authority

In practice, the OECD Multilateral Convention (MLI) does not change this treaty, because the United States is not among its signatories according to the OECD list. Its anti-abuse role is performed by Article 17.

The limitation-on-benefits clause and how an ETVE qualifies

An ETVE can only invoke the treaty if it is a "qualified person" under art. 17 or if it fits one of its alternative routes. Being resident in Spain is not enough. Each route has its own conditions, which must be read one by one.

  • Listed companies (art. 17.2.c) and their subsidiaries under certain conditions.
  • Ownership and base erosion (art. 17.2.e). At least 50% of the voting power and value must belong to residents of the same State as the company, in the categories provided for, on at least half the days of the tax year. Interposed entities, disproportionate classes and the limit on certain deductible payments are also reviewed.
  • Derivative benefits (art. 17.3). At least 95% of the voting power and value must be held by seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries. The State of the interposed entities, disproportionate classes, base erosion and the specific equivalence of the benefit are reviewed. The definition (art. 17.8.g) includes, in certain cases, residents of the Contracting States themselves.
  • Active conduct of a trade or business (art. 17.4): merely holding or managing investments does not count. Where the income comes from a related company, the activity in Spain must also be substantial.
  • Headquarters of a multinational group (art. 17.5): it requires, among other conditions, a group with a significant presence in at least five countries.
  • Discretionary grant by the US competent authority (art. 17.7).

Practical consequence: in our experience, an ETVE owned by a Mexican, Colombian or Venezuelan family investing in the US will find it difficult to meet the ownership test, and the derivative benefits route requires all of its conditions to be checked; the shareholders' residence in a country with a tax treaty is not enough on its own. This is a general assessment that depends on the facts of each structure. If the ETVE does not satisfy art. 17, the US subsidiary withholds the domestic 30% (Internal Revenue Code, §881 and §1442). This analysis must be carried out before placing a US subsidiary under the ETVE. See anti-abuse rules.

The US subsidiary of an ETVE

In Spain, the dividend may qualify under art. 21 of the Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS) if the requirements are met. The treaty route requires the treaty to be applicable to the subsidiary. Independently of that route, it may be evidenced that the subsidiary is subject, without exemption, to a similar tax at a nominal rate of at least 10%. Other requirements in requirements.

If the ETVE sells the subsidiary, the residual rule in art. 13 of the treaty allocates the taxing right to Spain as the seller's State of residence, once the specific rules have been ruled out, such as the rule for companies whose principal assets are US immovable property or the rule for property attributable to a permanent establishment. In Spain, the sale may qualify for the art. 21 exemption if the requirements are met.

The shareholder resident in the US of a Spanish ETVE

If the ETVE regime, the eligible origin of the dividend and the recipient's requirements are met, art. 108 LIS may exclude its Spanish source; one of those requirements is that the shareholder is not resident in a non-cooperative jurisdiction, and the United States is not one. Dividends that do not meet those conditions and are subject to Non-Resident Income Tax (IRNR) generally bear withholding tax at 19% (art. 25.1.f of the Texto refundido de la Ley del Impuesto sobre la Renta de no Residentes, the consolidated text of the Non-Resident Income Tax Act, TRLIRNR), unless exempt; art. 10 of the treaty limits it where the recipient is the beneficial owner and meets the applicable LOB. On a sale of the ETVE the same logic of art. 13 applies: the residual rule favours the seller's country, after examining the specific rules, such as the rule for immovable property located in Spain. More detail in distributions to non-resident shareholders.

Watch out for the territories. The US Virgin Islands, Guam, American Samoa and the Mariana Islands are on the Spanish list of non-cooperative jurisdictions. A shareholder resident there does not have the benefit of art. 108. The shareholder's residence and the territorial scope of the treaty are checked separately.

LLCs and partnerships as shareholders

For an LLC, its tax classification and who derives the income must be identified. To the extent that the US treats the income as derived by a US resident, art. 1.6 may attribute it to that resident for treaty purposes. The conditions of the specific benefit and its documentation must be checked.

The 2006 competent authority agreement (BOE of 13 August 2009) related to the previous wording of the treaty; it should not be extended without analysis to the current art. 1.6 or to all LLCs. For the classification of the entity for Spanish purposes, the Resolution of the Directorate General for Taxation of 6 February 2020 requires, under the law of the country of incorporation, that the entity is not a taxpayer of a personal income tax, that its income is attributed to the members by the mere fact of being obtained and that it retains its nature.

For that reason, a transparent LLC whose members are not resident in the US does not on its own give access to the treaty with the US. What matters is the residence and situation of each member.

How the shareholder is taxed in the US

An ETVE may be a CFC if qualifying US shareholders together own more than 50% of the voting power or value. Each qualifying shareholder owns at least 10% of the voting power or value. The attribution rules (§958) and the relevant special rules (§951(b) and §957 IRC) apply.

  • Subpart F. Dividends may be passive income. §954(c)(6), now permanent, excludes certain dividends, interest, royalties and rents between related CFCs to the extent that they derive from income of the payer that is neither Subpart F income nor income effectively connected with a US trade or business.
  • NCTI, formerly GILTI. For CFC tax years beginning after 31 December 2025, the reform of §951A applies. For corporate shareholders and subject to its limits, the §250 deduction is 40% and the indirect credit under §960(d) is calculated on 90% of the creditable foreign taxes.
  • Corporate shareholder. §245A may allow a US corporation to deduct the foreign-source portion of certain dividends. Among other limits, it requires more than 365 days within a 731-day window and excludes hybrid dividends. Distributions of profits already included in the shareholder's income follow their own rules (§959).
  • Minority shareholder: PFIC. An ETVE that only receives dividends may be a PFIC under §1297 if at least 75% of its gross income is passive, or if the average share of its assets producing or held to produce passive income is at least 50%. The PFIC tests take into account a proportionate share of the assets and income of corporations in which the ETVE owns at least 25% by value, directly or indirectly. If the ETVE is a CFC, the overlap rules may exclude PFIC treatment for qualifying shareholders.
  • Legal form. For US purposes, the Spanish sociedad anónima (S.A.) is always a corporation (Treas. Reg. §301.7701-2(b)(8)). The S.L. does not appear on that list: as an eligible foreign entity all of whose members have limited liability, it is in principle classified as a corporation, without prejudice to the election provided for in §301.7701-3. Choosing an S.L. or an S.A. has consequences in the US.

In short, the ETVE does not usually defer the taxation of a US shareholder. Its usefulness for them will lie in the organisation of the group, the reduction of withholding taxes at source or succession planning, not in deferral (family holding company).

US investor in Latin America through Spain

Spain has tax treaties with almost all of Latin America. According to the official IRS list, the United States has them only with Chile, Mexico and Venezuela in the region, as well as Barbados, Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago.

Subsidiary's country Tax treaty with the US Tax treaty with Spain
Chile Yes, with general effect from 1 January 2024 Yes
Mexico Yes Yes
Venezuela Yes Yes
Argentina, Brazil, Colombia No Yes
Peru No Signed, not in force

An ETVE may give access to the benefits of Spanish tax treaties in countries where the US has no double taxation treaty. For each flow, check the treaty in force, its protocol, the MLI effective date or the local clause, the beneficial owner and the shareholder's tax rules in the US. It is important to distinguish the treaty between Spain and the US, which governs the relationship with the shareholder, from the treaty between Spain and the country of each subsidiary. A lower withholding tax at source may also reduce the tax credit in the US. With Chile, the direct treaty with the US may make Spanish intermediation less useful (Chile).

What we review in a case involving the United States

  • Residence of each shareholder: in the US, in another country or in a US territory on the Spanish list.
  • Classification of the entity: whether the shareholder is an individual, a corporation, an LLC or a partnership, how the US and Spain classify it, and whether the ETVE is better set up as an S.L. or an S.A.
  • Art. 17 of the treaty: which LOB route the ETVE meets, shareholder by shareholder, before it has US subsidiaries.
  • CFC: whether the ETVE is a CFC and what Subpart F or NCTI means for each qualifying shareholder, with the US adviser.
  • PFIC: for US shareholders not covered by the CFC regime.
  • Immovable property and permanent establishments: assets in the US or in Spain that change the allocation under art. 13.
  • Tax treaties with the Latin American countries of the subsidiaries: anti-abuse clauses and beneficial owner in each.
  • Substance in Spain, which is the basis for all of the above (substance).

Is an ETVE right for you? Try the simulator: requirements check and an indicative Spanish tax cost.

Frequently asked questions

How much does the US withhold on dividends that a US subsidiary pays to an ETVE?

The domestic withholding tax is 30%. The treaty limits it to 15% as a general rule, to 5% if the ETVE directly holds at least 10% of the voting power and to 0% if, in addition to holding at least 80% of the voting power for 12 months, it meets the art. 17 routes required by art. 10.3. In all cases the ETVE must be the beneficial owner and satisfy the LOB clause; if it does not, it is not entitled to those reductions.

Does Spain withhold anything from a shareholder resident in the US when the ETVE distributes dividends?

If the ETVE regime, the eligible origin of the dividend and the recipient's requirements are met, art. 108 LIS may exclude its Spanish source. For dividends subject to Non-Resident Income Tax (IRNR), the treaty sets caps where the recipient is the beneficial owner and meets the applicable LOB.

Can a US LLC be a shareholder in an ETVE?

Yes, but it is necessary to identify how the US classifies it and who derives the income. To the extent that the US treats the income as derived by a US resident, art. 1.6 of the treaty may attribute it to that resident; in Spain, its classification as a flow-through entity follows the criteria of the Resolution of the DGT (Spanish Directorate General for Taxation) of 6 February 2020.

Is an ETVE useful for a US investor investing in Latin America?

It may give access to tax treaties that the US does not have, such as Spain's treaties with Argentina, Brazil or Colombia. But for each flow it is necessary to check the treaty in force, its anti-abuse clauses and the beneficial owner, and the US shareholder remains subject to its own rules (CFC or PFIC).

Does the US tax the sale of a US subsidiary by the ETVE?

Following the Protocol, the residual rule in art. 13 allocates the taxing right to the seller's State of residence. The specific rules of the article must first be ruled out, such as the rule for companies whose value derives from immovable property located in the US or the rule for property attributable to a permanent establishment.

Sources

This guide provides general information as of November 15, 2026 and is not advice on any specific case.

How we can help

For many years the firm has advised entrepreneurs and families from Latin America on setting up, acquiring, relocating and maintaining ETVEs: preliminary analysis, articles of association, contribution of shares, notification to the tax authorities, management from Spain and an annual substance review, in coordination with their local advisers.

The first meeting with René Dechamps Azanza, founder of the practice, is free of charge: in person in Madrid or by video call. Write to us at rda@rdalex.com or call +34 91 308 71 73.

Request a first meeting

Or call us on +34 91 308 71 73 · rda@rdalex.com

CallFirst meeting