ETVE guide · Spanish holding company

ETVE and France: French subsidiary, shareholder resident in France and relocation to Spain

Last reviewed:

A French subsidiary can pay dividends to a Spanish ETVE without withholding tax in France if the ETVE is the beneficial owner and holds at least 10% for 365 days (1995 tax treaty and MLI), or under the Parent-Subsidiary Directive if it meets its conditions. For a shareholder resident in France, Spain does not withhold tax on dividends that the ETVE distributes out of exempt foreign income, but France does tax them: the régime mère-fille if the shareholder is a company and, as a general rule, the PFU (prélèvement forfaitaire unique, flat tax) of 31.4% in 2026 if it is an individual. Arts. 209 B and 123 bis CGI on foreign entities have their own safeguards for EU entities, linked to the absence of an artificial arrangement.

By René Dechamps Azanza, lawyer (Madrid Bar no. 21.297), founder of the firm (1982)

In short

  • Spain-France tax treaty of 10 October 1995, in force since 1 July 1997 and modified by the MLI from 1 January 2023 (including the principal purpose clause).
  • Dividends from a French subsidiary to the ETVE: 0% in France with a direct or indirect 10% holding for 365 days; otherwise, a maximum of 15%.
  • French corporate shareholder: régime mère-fille (5% and two years; a share of costs normally of 5%, and of 1% only under the conditions of art. 216) and art. 209 B CGI, with its safeguard for EU entities.
  • Individual shareholder: as a general rule, PFU of 31.4% in 2026 (12.8% + 18.6%) or an overall election for the progressive scale; art. 123 bis CGI, with its own EU safeguard.
  • Anyone moving to Spain must review the exit tax in art. 167 bis CGI and, for succession, the 1963 convention, the pacte Dutreil and the Spanish family business relief.

France enters an ETVE through three doors: as the country of a subsidiary, as the country of the shareholder (company or individual) and as the country from which a family leaves to settle in Spain. French investors with investments in Latin America or outside the EU are those who can make the most of it.

Tax treaty between Spain and France

The treaty was signed in Madrid on 10 October 1995, published in the BOE on 12 June 1997 and has been in force since 1 July 1997. The Multilateral Convention (MLI) has modified it in both countries since 1 January 2023.

Issue What the treaty in force says
Dividends (art. 10.2.a) Maximum of 15% if the recipient is the beneficial owner
Dividends to a Spanish company (arts. 10.2.b.ii and 10.4.b) Taxed only in Spain if the recipient company holds, directly or indirectly, at least 10% of the capital
Dividends to a French company (art. 10.2.b.i) Taxed only in France if the French company directly holds at least 10% of the capital
Minimum holding period (art. 8 MLI) The exemption requires that holding for 365 days including the payment date
Sale of shares (art. 13.5) As a general rule, taxed only in the seller's country
Substantial holding (art. 13.2.a) The company's country may tax if the seller, alone or with their spouse, ascendants and descendants, held, directly or indirectly, at least 25% of the capital or profits in the preceding twelve months; art. 13.2.b has a special rule for reorganisations
Real estate companies (art. 9.4 MLI) Taxed where the immovable property is located if, in the preceding 365 days, more than 50% of their value derived from it
Residence of companies (art. 4.3) Where its place of effective management is situated
Anti-abuse (art. 7 MLI) Principal purpose clause
Domestic rules (Protocol, point 16) The treaty does not prevent France from applying art. 209 B CGI

The treaty allocates taxing rights; whether, and how, a State exercises them is decided by its domestic law.

The French subsidiary of an ETVE

A French subsidiary can distribute to the ETVE without withholding tax under the treaty or under the parent-subsidiary exemption, if their conditions are met. Without either, France withholds 25% from non-resident companies (arts. 119 bis and 187 CGI).

  • Treaty: the ETVE as beneficial owner, a direct or indirect 10% holding and 365 days.
  • Parent-subsidiary exemption (art. 119 ter CGI, which implements Directive 2011/96/EU). The ETVE must be the beneficial owner and meet the residence, legal form and liability-to-tax requirements of the article, with a direct holding of at least 10% for two years or an undertaking to maintain it on the terms of the article. The threshold falls to 5% where the conditions of art. 145 CGI are met and the ETVE cannot credit the French withholding tax. The anti-abuse clause examines the purpose of the benefit and the genuineness of the arrangement.

In Spain, the dividend qualifies for the 95% exemption in art. 21 LIS (5% and one year). France meets the minimum taxation requirement in both ways: its corporate income tax is 25% (art. 219 CGI), above the 10% nominal rate, and the treaty provides for exchange of information (art. 27). If the ETVE sells the subsidiary and held 25% or more of the capital or profits in the preceding twelve months, the treaty allows France to tax the capital gain (art. 13.2.a), as it also does if the subsidiary is a real estate company within the meaning of art. 9.4 MLI. Whether France actually taxes it depends on its domestic law, which governs the taxation of non-residents in art. 244 bis B CGI; any exemption or refund for an EU company must be checked in each case. Details in requirements.

Shareholders resident in France

Spain does not tax the French shareholder on dividends that the ETVE pays out of exempt foreign income; France does. France is not a non-cooperative jurisdiction.

  • Dividends out of exempt income: they are not regarded as obtained in Spain (art. 108 LIS).
  • Other dividends. The treaty sets a maximum of 15% for the beneficial owner and exclusive taxation in France for a French company that is the beneficial owner and directly holds at least 10% for 365 days including the payment date (art. 10.2.b.i and art. 8 MLI). Separately, the Spanish exemption for EU parent companies in art. 14.1.h TRLIRNR may apply, with its own requirements.
  • Sale of the ETVE. The portion attributable to exempt reserves and to capital gains on subsidiaries that meet art. 21 has no Spanish source (art. 108.2.b LIS). For the remainder, the general rule is taxation in France (art. 13.5), but the real estate rule (art. 9.4 MLI), the substantial holding of 25% of the capital or profits, direct or indirect, in the preceding twelve months (art. 13.2.a), and the special paragraph on reorganisations (art. 13.2.b) must first be checked. The assessment also depends on Spanish domestic law.

More in distributions to non-resident shareholders.

French corporate shareholder: régime mère-fille and art. 209 B CGI

For a French company, the ETVE does not improve Spanish dividends: they can already arrive without withholding tax under the Directive, if its conditions are met. The advantage lies in subsidiaries outside the EU and in the sale.

  • Régime mère-fille (arts. 145 and 216 CGI). A French company subject to IS (French corporate income tax) may exclude dividends from its tax base if it holds at least 5% for two years and meets the holding, legal form and liability-to-tax conditions of art. 145, which also excludes, among other cases, subsidiaries in non-cooperative States according to the French list. A share of costs is taxed, normally 5%. The 1% rate requires the specific conditions of art. 216, including, where relevant, that both companies could form a hypothetical French tax group during the required period; reaching a percentage or the ETVE being resident in the EU is not enough.
  • Art. 209 B CGI. It may tax a French company that holds, directly or indirectly, more than 50% of a foreign entity with a privileged tax regime; in certain cases of collective ownership the threshold is lower. To determine whether there is a privileged regime (art. 238 A), the foreign tax is compared with the tax that would be due in France on equivalent income. For an EU entity, the article excludes its application unless there is an artificial arrangement as defined by the article itself. That is why the ETVE needs real substance in Spain.

Individual shareholder resident in France

  • Dividend. For an individual tax-domiciled in France, the ordinary 2026 regime combines 12.8% income tax and, as a general rule, 18.6% prélèvements sociaux (31.4% in total). There are exceptions to the social levies depending on personal circumstances, and the election for the progressive scale is overall, not dividend by dividend. If there were Spanish tax, the credit allowed by the treaty applies (art. 24.1.a).
  • Art. 123 bis CGI. It may attribute to a French resident holding at least 10% the profits of a foreign entity under a privileged regime whose assets are mainly financial, such as those of a holding company. It also has a safeguard for EU entities linked to the absence of an artificial arrangement, with a test that does not exactly coincide with that of art. 209 B.

The ETVE does not reduce the shareholder's French tax: it allows reinvestment without distribution and the organisation of the group.

Exit tax: moving from France to Spain with the holding company

Anyone leaving France may become subject to the exit tax in art. 167 bis CGI; if they move to another EU Member State, such as Spain, the automatic deferral of payment may apply.

  • Who it affects: anyone who was resident in France for six of the previous ten years and holds at least 50% of the profits of a company or holdings worth more than €800,000.
  • What it taxes: the latent capital gain at the date of the move and, under its own rules, other income whose taxation had been deferred.
  • Move within the EU. The automatic deferral may apply. Any discharge after two or five years (depending on the value of the holdings) relates to the latent capital gain covered by that rule and requires that no event ending the deferral has occurred. The returns required at the time of the move and in the following years depend on each case and must be checked.

Once in Spain, the shareholder is taxed on the ETVE's dividends under Spanish personal income tax (IRPF), as savings income (art. 108.1 LIS). See moving to Spain with a holding company.

Pacte Dutreil compared with the Spanish family business regime

Both regimes ease the transfer of a family business, with different requirements.

Pacte Dutreil (art. 787 B CGI) Spanish family business
Benefit Exemption of 75% of the value covered by art. 787 B State reduction of 95% under art. 20.2.c of Law 29/1987 for inheritances and under art. 20.6 for gifts; regional legislation may provide for its own reductions, which must be checked
Commitment Collective commitment of 2 years and individual commitment of 6 years (transfers from 21/02/2026) State reduction: retain the acquisition for 10 years from the death (art. 20.2.c); for gifts, retain what was acquired and the entitlement to the Wealth Tax exemption for 10 years from the deed (art. 20.6.c)
Management A signatory or heir manages the business during the commitment and for three further years Management functions with more than 50% of earned income (art. 4.Ocho.Dos of Law 19/1991)
Holding company A holding animatrice may be eligible. Foreign companies meeting the same conditions as French companies may also qualify; for indirect holdings there are interposition rules The activity and business-use test applies. For certain holdings not to be counted as asset-holding, the Wealth Tax Act requires at least 5% of the voting rights, that they are held to direct and manage the investee with the corresponding organisation of resources, and the other conditions
Exclusions Luxury assets not used in the business (from 2026) Assets not used in the activity

Which State taxes the inheritance and which relief applies

In a Franco-Spanish succession, the convention of 8 January 1963 applies first; its inheritance part remains in force (art. 32.3 of the 1995 treaty). Its art. 34 generally allocates movable securities, such as shares and holdings, to the State of residence of the deceased at the time of death, subject to the exceptions in arts. 31 and 32. The residence of the deceased and the nature of each asset must be determined: the residence of an heir does not on its own decide which State has taxing rights. The convention does not apply to gifts, which are analysed separately.

The following are then examined separately:

  • The Spanish reduction. The State 95% reduction or the applicable regional one. In the Comunidad de Madrid, Law 3/2026 of 30 June, in force since 1 July 2026, introduced its own 99% reduction for certain acquisitions of businesses and holdings, with requirements as to kinship, holding, management functions and retention for five years. It only applies where Madrid legislation is applicable and cannot be combined with the State reduction.
  • French eligibility of the holding company. If French law comes into play, a foreign company, such as the ETVE, may qualify for the pacte Dutreil if it meets all the conditions required of a French company.

More in family holding company.

SCI, SAS or Spanish S.L.

Each vehicle serves a different purpose.

  • SCI. A civil company for real estate. It does not replace the ETVE: real estate within an ETVE may turn it into an asset-holding entity.
  • SAS holding company. It has the régime mère-fille. But for non-resident shareholders outside the EU, France withholds tax on dividends (art. 187 CGI), unless a tax treaty provides otherwise.
  • Spanish S.L. as an ETVE. 95% exemption and distributions free of withholding tax to non-resident shareholders out of exempt income (art. 108 LIS), subject to its requirements. Useful with subsidiaries in Latin America and shareholders in several countries.

A broader comparison in ETVE compared with other European holding companies.

Abus de droit and anti-abuse clauses

France may recharacterise a structure with no real economic rationale, subject to the requirements and procedure of each clause.

  • Art. L64 LPF. It allows sham transactions and cases of fraus legis with an exclusively tax purpose to be recharacterised. The penalty may be 80% or be reduced to 40% in the case provided for in art. 1729.b CGI.
  • Art. L64 A LPF. It governs abuse with a principal tax purpose within its temporal scope, expressly reserving the application of the IS clause in art. 205 A CGI.
  • Art. 205 A CGI: for IS, non-genuine arrangements, not put into place for "valid commercial reasons", whose main purpose is to obtain a tax advantage that defeats the object or purpose of the rule.

On the treaty side, art. 7 MLI applies. See anti-abuse rules.

Investment protection agreement

This section covers the APPRIs (bilateral investment treaties) with Latin American countries. Between Spain and France the EU freedoms apply, which are not equivalent to an APPRI. See treaties and agreements.

What we review in a French case

  • Type of shareholder: company (mère-fille, 209 B) or individual (PFU, 123 bis).
  • Percentages and periods: 10% and 365 days under the treaty; 5% and two years in France; 5% and one year in Spain; 25% of the capital or profits on a sale, and the real estate rule.
  • Substance and place of management in Spain, to rule out an artificial arrangement.
  • Documented economic reasons (art. 7 MLI, L64 and 205 A).
  • Change of residence: exit tax and timing.
  • Succession: 1963 convention, Dutreil and Spanish reduction, State or regional.
  • Coordination with the French adviser.

Is an ETVE right for you? Try the simulator: requirements check and an indicative Spanish tax cost.

Frequently asked questions

How much does France withhold on dividends that a French subsidiary pays to a Spanish ETVE?

Nothing, if the ETVE is the beneficial owner and holds, directly or indirectly, at least 10% of the capital for 365 days including the payment date (art. 10.2.b of the treaty and art. 8 MLI). Outside that case, the treaty maximum is 15%; the parent-subsidiary exemption in art. 119 ter CGI is an alternative route, with its own conditions and anti-abuse clause.

Does a French company gain anything by holding its subsidiaries through an ETVE?

On Spanish dividends, little: an EU parent can already receive them from a Spanish company without withholding tax if it meets the conditions of art. 14.1.h of the Texto refundido de la Ley del Impuesto sobre la Renta de no Residentes (consolidated text of the Non-Resident Income Tax Act, TRLIRNR). The ETVE makes sense for subsidiaries outside the EU, for non-resident shareholders that are not EU companies and for the sale of the holding company.

I live in France. How is the dividend paid to me by the ETVE taxed?

Spain does not withhold tax if it derives from exempt foreign income (art. 108 of the Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades, the Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS). In France it is taxed as a dividend: in 2026, as a general rule, 12.8% income tax plus 18.6% prélèvements sociaux (social levies), subject to personal exceptions, or the progressive scale if the overall election is made.

If I move from France to Spain, do I pay exit tax?

It may apply if you were resident in France for six of the previous ten years and hold at least 50% of the profits of a company or holdings worth more than €800,000. On moving to another EU Member State, the automatic deferral of payment may apply; any discharge after two or five years affects the latent capital gain covered by that rule and depends on the value of the holdings and on no event occurring that ends the deferral.

If I die while resident in Spain, which country taxes my shares?

The Franco-Spanish convention of 8 January 1963 remains in force as regards inheritance: its art. 34 generally allocates shares and holdings to the State of residence of the deceased at the time of death, subject to the exceptions in arts. 31 and 32. It does not apply to gifts, which are analysed separately.

Can a French company become an ETVE?

The ETVE is a Spanish company, so it would be necessary to transfer its registered office to Spain or incorporate a new one. A cross-border transfer preserves legal personality, but it has tax consequences in France that must be analysed beforehand.

Sources

This guide provides general information as of November 15, 2026 and is not advice on any specific case.

How we can help

For many years the firm has advised entrepreneurs and families from Latin America on setting up, acquiring, relocating and maintaining ETVEs: preliminary analysis, articles of association, contribution of shares, notification to the tax authorities, management from Spain and an annual substance review, in coordination with their local advisers.

The first meeting with René Dechamps Azanza, founder of the practice, is free of charge: in person in Madrid or by video call. Write to us at rda@rdalex.com or call +34 91 308 71 73.

Request a first meeting

Or call us on +34 91 308 71 73 · rda@rdalex.com

CallFirst meeting