ETVE substance: material and human resources, decisions taken in Spain and the annual substance records
Last reviewed:
The Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS) requires the ETVE to manage its foreign shareholdings «through the corresponding organisation of material and human resources» (art. 107.1 LIS), without specifying any number of employees or an office. Whether the resources are sufficient depends on the portfolio and on who actually exercises the rights and takes the decisions concerning it: it is advisable to be able to show which person decides, what powers they hold and how they exercise them. Beneficial ownership requirements, anti-abuse clauses and the legislation of the countries of the shareholders and of the subsidiaries may demand more, in proportion to the size of the group.
By René Dechamps Azanza, lawyer (Madrid Bar no. 21.297), founder of the firm (1982)
In short
- The resources are required of the ETVE, not of its subsidiaries, and must genuinely serve to manage the shareholdings.
- Decisions must be taken in Spain by people with real powers and autonomy: a notarial power of attorney is no substitute for the board or governing body.
- Accounting, company secretarial work and the registered office may be outsourced; investment decisions may not.
- Complying with the Spanish regime does not guarantee meeting other countries' beneficial ownership requirements and anti-abuse clauses.
- A substance file, reviewed and closed every year, is advisable.
What the law requires: resources to manage, not a number of employees
Article 107.1 LIS makes the regime available to companies whose corporate purpose includes the management and administration of securities in non-resident entities «through the corresponding organisation of material and human resources». It sets no number of employees, office floor space or budget.
Three clarifications:
- The resources are required of the ETVE, not of its subsidiaries.
- The point is to manage securities, not to run the subsidiaries. Managing securities means voting at general meetings, appointing directors, collecting dividends, financing investments and deciding on acquisitions and disposals. Running the business of each subsidiary is a different matter, and requires more.
- There are other tests, distinct from this one. Resources also matter to ensure that the ETVE is not a passive holding entity (entidad patrimonial) (art. 5.2 LIS). Tax residence (art. 8.1 LIS) is examined separately: being resident in Spain does not prove that there is genuine management, nor vice versa.
What the DGT and the courts have said
Administrative doctrine offers no automatic sufficiency rule. The international taxation manual of the Instituto de Estudios Fiscales (Spanish Institute for Fiscal Studies, IEF) summarises as follows the criteria it attributes to the Dirección General de Tributos (Directorate General of Taxes, DGT):
- What matters is who really decides. Whether the resources are sufficient depends on the portfolio and on who actually exercises the rights and takes the decisions concerning it. It is advisable to be able to show which person decides, what powers they hold and how they exercise them.
- A governing body made up solely of people provided by service companies (law firms, accountancy firms or trust offices) is difficult to defend if it does not exercise autonomous management.
- Excessively restricting the powers of the director, for example to buy or sell shareholdings, may mean the requirement is not met.
- The law does not require employees or an owned or leased office. Administrative tasks may be outsourced; a registered office is essential.
We do not cite specific ruling numbers here: the relevant administrative doctrine and case law are set out, with their references, in doctrine and case law.
In the European Union, the benchmark is the so-called «Danish cases»: two judgments of the Court of Justice of 26 February 2019, one on dividends (Joined Cases C-116/16 and C-117/16) and the other on interest (C-115/16 and joined cases). The Court accepted that the benefits of the directives may be denied to intermediate companies acting as conduits. Passing income on shortly after receiving it is an indication. It is assessed together with the power to dispose of that income, who decides, the company's resources and the other circumstances of the case: abuse is assessed as a whole.
In Spain, the Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal, TEAC), in its decision of 27 January 2026 (RG 00/02180/2022) on dividends, places the burden of proving abuse on the tax authorities. That does not relieve the company of keeping evidence of its own management.
The board or governing body: the core of substance
The board or governing body must have real powers and exercise them in Spain. This is the first thing that is examined.
The Ley de Sociedades de Capital (Spanish Companies Act, LSC) allows a sole director, several joint and several directors, several joint directors or a board of directors (art. 210 LSC). The director may be an individual or a legal entity and need not be a shareholder (art. 212 LSC).
We generally recommend a board of directors. This is the firm's guideline, not a legal requirement:
- with at least one director who has thorough knowledge of the investments, even if resident abroad (often the business owner or a family member);
- with a majority of directors resident in Spain and meetings held here, to reinforce that the place of effective management is in Spain;
- with a managing director (consejero delegado) or executive committee, if agility is needed, registered with the Commercial Registry (art. 249 LSC).
What does not work:
- A notarial power of attorney granted to a resident. The attorney-in-fact executes; they do not decide.
- Directors who merely sign what was decided elsewhere, or who lack powers to invest and divest.
- A director without real autonomy. The evidence must show who effectively exercises the management powers over the shareholdings. If the director is an external professional, it is advisable to set out their duties precisely and to distinguish the performance of the office from the services provided by their firm.
The nationality of the directors is irrelevant; what matters is where they reside and where they decide.
Example: how to prove that the governing body decides
Useful evidence shows the decision-making process, not just its outcome. Suppose the ETVE sells a subsidiary. A robust file would include:
- The sale proposal, with the valuation and the alternatives, sent to the directors before the meeting.
- The notice of meeting and the minutes of the board meeting held in Spain: who attended, what was discussed, what objections were raised and how the vote went.
- The resolution setting the minimum price, the terms and the person authorised to sign.
- The board's instructions to the attorney-in-fact and the contract signed within those limits.
- Receipt of the price and its use (reinvestment, distribution or treasury), approved by the governing body.
If the minutes merely ratify a contract already negotiated and signed abroad, the evidence is weakened, even if the formalities have been observed.
Effective management in Spain and risk in other countries
An ETVE incorporated in Spain is resident here (art. 8.1 LIS). The risk comes from abroad: if decisions are taken in the shareholder's country, that State may consider the ETVE resident there or regard it as a permanent establishment. In the event of dual residence, the applicable treaty must be read, together with the amendments made by the Multilateral Convention (MLI) where relevant. Some treaties use the place of effective management, while others require mutual agreement between competent authorities.
What proves management in Spain:
- minutes of board and general meetings held in Spain that reflect the discussion, not just the resolution;
- emails, reports and proposals showing who decides;
- voting instructions for the general meetings of the subsidiaries;
- treasury documentation, bank authorisations and traceability of receipts and payments supervised by the board or governing body;
- accounting records and documentation kept at the registered office.
What can and cannot be outsourced
Support can be outsourced; decision-making cannot.
| Function | Can it be outsourced? | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Registered office and notifications | Yes | Must allow documentation to be kept and the board to meet |
| Accounting, taxes, annual accounts | Yes | Under the supervision of the governing body |
| Board secretarial work, minutes | Yes | The content is decided by the board |
| Legal, tax and valuation advice | Yes | Advises; does not decide |
| Investment and divestment decisions | No | A matter for the board or governing body |
| Exercise of voting rights in the subsidiaries | Yes, by proxy | The ETVE decides how to vote and documents its instructions |
| Dividend and financing policy | No | Resolution of the governing body, with documented discussion |
| Bank signing authority | Only partially | Attorneys-in-fact execute the governing body's orders |
Proportionality: substance grows with the group
There is no fixed threshold: the resources must be proportionate to what the ETVE holds and does. An ETVE with one subsidiary does not need the structure of the holding company of a group with twenty companies. The following three levels are the firm's guidelines, not legal requirements:
- Family ETVE with one or two subsidiaries: a board with one knowledgeable director and a resident majority, two or three meetings a year in Spain, documented treasury, and outsourced registered office and accounting.
- Medium-sized group with several subsidiaries in several countries: in addition, an owned or leased office and some resident executive, possibly registered with Social Security.
- Regional holding company: genuine treasury, group financing or business development functions carried out from Spain. If it provides services to its subsidiaries, its fees must be at arm's length and documented (annual obligations).
The order matters: shortcomings are corrected first and documented afterwards.
Why other countries may require more evidence of substance
A simple structure may be enough for the Spanish regime; for the beneficial ownership requirements and anti-abuse clauses of other States, perhaps not.
- Subsidiary's country. The treaty may require the ETVE to be the beneficial owner and may be subject to a principal purpose test. The Parent-Subsidiary Directive has its own requirements and an anti-abuse rule. The rule applicable to each payment must be checked. The IEF manual reports that Central American States have begun to request information on the resources of ETVEs and their reasons.
- Shareholder's country. If the ETVE is managed from there, that country may consider it resident or tax its income under its CFC rules (see anti-abuse rules and countries).
- Spanish law itself demands more of European holding companies receiving dividends from Spain: the exemption in art. 14.1.h of the texto refundido de la Ley del Impuesto sobre la Renta de no Residentes (consolidated text of the Spanish Non-Resident Income Tax Act, TRLIRNR) does not apply if the majority of the voting rights in the parent company is held, directly or indirectly, by persons not resident in the EU or in States of the European Economic Area with effective exchange of information, unless there are «valid economic reasons and substantive business reasons».
- Banks. Banks ask for identification of the ultimate beneficial owner, the source of funds and who makes the decisions. An empty structure has difficulty opening and maintaining an account.
- European Union. The Directive against shell entities (ATAD 3) has not been adopted. The Commission's 2026 work programme included the proposal in the list of withdrawals. Spanish rules and the conditions of the applicable treaty, directive or foreign legislation continue to apply.
The annual substance file
It is a folder that gathers, for each financial year, the evidence that the ETVE is managed from Spain. It is opened on incorporation and closed with the annual accounts.
Recommended contents:
- Current articles of association, appointments and CVs of the directors (why they are qualified to manage the investments).
- Tax residence certificates of the resident directors.
- Calendar and minutes of board and general meetings, with the agenda and the documentation reviewed.
- Resolutions on investments, dividends and financing, with their justification.
- Voting instructions and minutes of the general meetings of the subsidiaries.
- Bank statements and treasury documentation showing dividends coming in and going out.
- Contracts for the registered office, office premises, staff and outsourced services.
- Accounting records, filed accounts and, where applicable, the audit report.
- Transfer pricing documentation for intra-group services and, where applicable, Form 232 (modelo 232).
- A brief memorandum of the economic reasons and the group's business plan.
- The ETVE's Spanish tax residence certificate for the subsidiaries.
Checklist
Green: met and documented. Amber: met, without sufficient evidence. Red: not met. Some items (residence of directors, meetings) are recommendations of the firm, not legal requirements.
| Item | Green if… |
|---|---|
| Board or governing body | Board (or director) with full powers to invest and divest |
| Knowledge | At least one director genuinely knows the investments |
| Residence | Majority of directors resident in Spain |
| Meetings | Board and general meetings in Spain, with minutes reflecting the discussion |
| Powers of attorney | Attorneys-in-fact execute resolutions; they do not replace the governing body |
| Subsidiaries | The ETVE decides how to vote and documents its instructions |
| Treasury | Receipts and payments traceable, authorised and supervised by the governing body |
| Registered office | Registered office where the documentation is kept |
| Outsourcing | Clear contracts; no outsourced decisions |
| Resources | Staff, office and budget proportionate to the group |
| Countries | Beneficial ownership, the PPT and the shareholder's CFC rules reviewed |
| File | Closed and archived with the accounts for the year |
A red in the first items seriously weakens the defence of the regime. Several ambers may be difficult to defend before another country. It is advisable to review it at each year-end and before each significant distribution.
Is an ETVE right for you? Try the simulator: requirements check and an indicative Spanish tax cost.
Frequently asked questions
Does the ETVE need its own employees and office?
The law does not require them. What is decisive is being able to show who decides on the shareholdings, with what powers and how they exercise them. Depending on the size of the group, staff or an office strengthen the structure, particularly vis-à-vis other countries.
Can the director of the ETVE be non-resident?
Yes, the law imposes no residence or nationality requirement. However, if decisions are taken abroad, another State may consider the ETVE to be resident there. For that reason, the firm generally recommends a board of directors with a majority of resident directors and meetings held in Spain.
Is it enough to grant a notarial power of attorney to a person resident in Spain?
No. A person authorised solely to carry out instructions under a power of attorney does not make the company’s decisions. Substance requires the board or governing body to take the decisions in Spain and to be able to prove it.
Can an external professional act as director?
The law does not prevent it. What matters is that whoever holds the office effectively and autonomously exercises the management powers over the shareholdings. It is advisable to set out their duties precisely and to distinguish the performance of the office from the services provided by their firm.
What is beneficial ownership and why does it affect the ETVE?
The beneficial owner is the person who receives income for their own benefit and is free to dispose of it, not as a mere intermediary. If the subsidiary's country considers that the ETVE merely passes the funds on, it may deny it the reduced treaty rate of withholding tax; onward payment is an indication that is assessed together with the other circumstances. The Parent-Subsidiary Directive has its own requirements and an anti-abuse rule.
Sources
- Ley 27/2014, del Impuesto sobre Sociedades (Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act), arts. 5, 8.1 and 107 (consolidated text)
- Real Decreto Legislativo 5/2004, consolidated text of the Ley del IRNR (Spanish Non-Resident Income Tax Act), art. 14.1.h
- Real Decreto Legislativo 1/2010, Ley de Sociedades de Capital (Spanish Companies Act), arts. 210, 212 and 249
- Multilateral Convention (MLI), arts. 4 and 7 (BOE of 22/12/2021)
- Spanish Ministry of Finance, double taxation conventions and synthesised texts
- Directive 2011/96/EU, Parent-Subsidiary Directive, art. 1
- CJEU, judgment of 26/02/2019, Joined Cases C-116/16 and C-117/16 (dividends)
- CJEU, judgment of 26/02/2019, Case C-115/16 and joined cases (interest)
- TEAC, decision of 27/01/2026, RG 00/02180/2022
- European Commission, 2026 work programme, COM(2025) 870, Annex IV
- Instituto de Estudios Fiscales (Spanish Institute for Fiscal Studies), Manual de Fiscalidad Internacional (International Taxation Manual), ch. 58 (ETVE regime)
- Tax rulings of the Dirección General de Tributos (Directorate General of Taxes) (official search engine)
This guide provides general information as of November 15, 2026 and is not advice on any specific case.
How we can help
For many years the firm has advised entrepreneurs and families from Latin America on setting up, acquiring, relocating and maintaining ETVEs: preliminary analysis, articles of association, contribution of shares, notification to the tax authorities, management from Spain and an annual substance review, in coordination with their local advisers.
The first meeting with René Dechamps Azanza, founder of the practice, is free of charge: in person in Madrid or by video call. Write to us at rda@rdalex.com or call +34 91 308 71 73.
Request a first meetingOr call us on +34 91 308 71 73 · rda@rdalex.com
